Baroque it's my favorite period. I just have to go on record as staying I find Vivaldi repetitive and unoriginal.
Hey just because Vivaldi wrote the same concerto grosso 500 times doesn't mean he's repetitive and unoriginal, whassamatta w/ u?
I'm ok w/ his stuff only in the sense it's so predictable I can work while listening to it and NEVER end up distracted by some discovery as in other Baroque works like oh wow never realized another voice pops in there right before before the modulation. No. But it's not elevator music so I like it for background. My brain listens for a couple minutes and must figure Vivaldi is not a threat, so surely it's ok to ignore it.
Thems fighting words!
I am no huge fan of the Baroque. My musical era is the 19th Century with Mahler and Richard Strauss taking me in to the early 20th.
But! I will always fight Vivaldi's corner. I am an unashamed admirer of Vivaldi's inventiveness. And no, that doesn't mean just the Four Seasons.
Personally, I much prefer Vivaldi to Bach with his dreary religious mania. The album covers influence me probably; Need a Bach album cover? Check our stock of suffering Christs nailed to a piece of wood and choose one. Done and dusted.
It is a philosophical world view I have not much stomach for.
Bach apparently liked him well enough to *cough* transcribe (read copy) his concertos. It is known now that Bach transcribed 11 Vivaldi concertos.
Now Antonio Vivaldi? Lots of sunshine and wine and song and dancing and Venetian mists over the lagoon… Life.
Stravinsky said famously Vivaldi wrote the same concerto 400 times over and the slander stuck. Ever since then people have just taken it for granted and repeated it. Because, yeah, Igor. Also bear in mind that when Stravinsky said that Vivaldi had only recently been rediscovered (1959). Not a lot was known about his music.
Give him another try. Stray beyond the Four Seasons and listen to the HIP orchestras. They do magic.
He is directly emotional and that is no bad thing. Sure, he is fond of using circular progressions. But more often than not he uses these themes in a very creative way.
Now, Mozart? Goodness knows, he is yawn inducing! Apart from the last few symphonies, Don Giovanni and Nozze di Figaro? I give him a miss.
I'll now go and have a lie down.