Just for clarification
The incident happened in 2016.
The settlement was 2018.
As for why you (?) hadn't heard any rumors of this, it's because as with almost anything involving Musk the severance came with a powerful NDA. Just as his first wife about those. It was a friend who released the information, who isn't a party to the NDA. As far as the timing, one should obviously question, but it does come on the heels of another woman filed suit last year against the company for sexual harassment. The friend of the woman who got the severance claimed she did it for other survivors of such encounters. As with such things you probably know they are never revealed at the time, but tend to build like water in a damn. At some point these things get out, and it's rarely just one incident. It's when victims feel empowered to band together against something powerful, we finally hear more stories.
The timing is I am sure as coincidental though as Musk's sudden pivot to be a republican, while claiming to an advocate for free speech while slapping NDA's & hiring private investigators to smear someone on Twitter.
Sorry, meant to respond to this earlier.
Regarding the claim last year, my understanding that was against the company, not Musk personally? Aka Musk was not the one accused for committing sexual harassment.
Just because Tesla or any other company is being sued over sexual harassment does not mean he’s a predator. Most giant companies have such suits- just google any company- Apple, Ford, Goldman Sachs, CVS, LL Bean, McDonalds, John Deere, etc. If the allegations are true, it certainly does not reflect well on him as a leader. Tesla allegedly handles most HR problems quite poorly whether it be racism, working conditions, factory safety, etc. Let’s not forget Musk refused to shut down production of Tesla during the pandemic, against state law. I think he’s made quite clear the business and production rate is far more important than the people.
Harvey Weinstein had many NDA’s yet everyone in Hollywood apparently knew his MO as an open secret. Same story with Bill Cosby and R. Kelly and Larry Nassar (via USA Gymnastics, etc). These powerful men who abuse women often have a clear pattern of behavior. The more NDAs, the more likely people will know who aren’t supposed to.
I will also say I don’t even think NDAs should be allowed to cover up sexual harassment and definitely not cases of sexual assault as all too often they are used to conceal a pattern of heinous behavior. If the parties want to settle quietly out of court for harassment, fine, but it shouldn’t involve an NDA- or at least be up to the victim if they wish to remain anonymous. If there’s a crime involved, that’s for the criminal Justice system to handle first.
One of Musk’s tweets, I believe the first or one of the first, said “there’s more to the story” which is an interesting comment to make. It’s not exactly an outright denial. Not quite sure what that means.
The fact he tweeted about joining the GOP and to expect bad press is awfully convenient for him when hours before he was contacted for comment on the original article. Especially after the left wing media had already turned on him.
But it is interesting if this release was, as you suggested, politically motivated (I would assume relevant to the twitter takeover given the now known timing). The friend barrier the story for years while many people on the left fawned over him but as soon as Musk is seen as an bad guy for his political views, then the story gets released. I don’t know about you but I don’t think things should work that way.
On the other hand, $250,000 doesn’t seem like a lot of money for someone being inappropriately propositioned, exposed to, and retaliated against. Especially when you’re seeking restitution one of the richest and most high profile men and companies on earth. Women have received tens of millions for sexual harassment without physical abuse- granted typically with extended terms of harassment and in some cases higher profile jobs, but in most cases their bosses are not Elon Musk-level notoriety and they are not exposing themselves.
Another thing I find interesting situation is that this sorry was leaked to Insider of all outlets. It just seems like a rather low-on-the-totem pole kind of choice. Not exactly WaPo or NYT- or did they not want to publish a story based on such loose grounds.
Part of the problem here is that we’re getting the story from a third hand source reporting on a second hand source (who won’t ever answer questions herself) who allegedly knows the details of the NDA-bound victims claimed experience. So there’s really no way to even verify with the victim the accuracy of the reporting or hear her side of the story directly and not on the 6 year old recollection of someone else. If Musk really wants to battle this, release the alleged victim from her NDA and let her prove her side of the story and Musk his. Obviously he won’t do that.
I suspect no one disagrees they were on the plane and she gave him a massage. I suspect there is little-no evidence to support whatever his side of the story is and likewise little to support her. My question is who else was on this plane besides the pilots?
Is it possible Musk propositioned her for sex in exchange for a hose and flashed her? While I wouldn’t say it’s consistent with his public persona, it’s certainly a possibility. The rest of the story sounds like exactly what Musk would do to someone making allegations.
Just out of legal curiosity, if the friend was aware of the situation was this known to SpaceX at the time? If so why didn’t the lawyers pay her off too? Or did they not even ask? Or do they assume a second hand account would have no credibility? Seems like an obvious loose end to tie up when talking about an NDA for a situation that already occurred.
And can we just pause for a moment and just ponder why all these billionaires propositioning random people to become massage therapists? Seems like you’d want to find the good massage therapist and then suggest she become your flight attendant too. It takes a lot longer to train as a message therapist than a flight attendant.
I’m also curious to know the logistics of getting a massage on a Gulfstream G650. It’s one of the bigger planes as far as business jets and you can walk down the center standing up straight, but there’s not exactly a lot of space for a massage table let alone walking around it without banging into furniture and sides of the ceiling.