I mean, if you're hell bent on ignoring spatial computing which they said is the reason behind this design, then sure, it might seem arbitrary.
How are we feeling about iOS 26?
- Thread starter Eric
- Start date
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2021
- Posts
- 7,632
- Main Camera
- Sony
I don’t like that now if I want to print an email message I have to remember to scroll all the way to the bottom of the message to find the little “arrow” button, instead of it being visible at all times.
Stop hiding UI elements, Tim.
Maybe the new guy will fix that kind of stuff.
overall I do like the 26.x, though. It did make some things better from a UX perspective (more buttons look like buttons, etc.)
Stop hiding UI elements, Tim.
Maybe the new guy will fix that kind of stuff.
overall I do like the 26.x, though. It did make some things better from a UX perspective (more buttons look like buttons, etc.)
I'm confused. Can't you just print from the share sheet button?
Yeah I like that buttons look more like UI now, less like abstract symbols
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2021
- Posts
- 7,632
- Main Camera
- Sony
ain’t no share sheet button on iPadOS. It’s a curvy arrow button, and it’s on the content view, not in the chrome. So to get to it, if you have a long email, you need to scroll to the bottom of the email to see the left curvy arrow button.
In fact, iOS also doesn’t have the share sheet button, but at least it puts the left curvy arrow button in the chrome (in a floating toolbar on the bottom).
Yeah I recently upgraded and it seems ... okay so far, but there are a few hidden UI element things which really shouldn't be hidden that then pop out. Like I have no issue with hiding additional layers of UI complexity but at least on my 12 mini I don't know about anyone else (maybe larger phones its better), almost all the camera options even on the same "layer" are hidden - yes I understand that with lots options you might have to scroll, but I see two unless I start scrolling. That's a good example. The new Safari UI took some getting used to ... again ... but I'm almost adjusted to it already. Aesthetically yes, buttons that look like buttons is better. Overall the glass aesthetic looks fine, though I'm using the less transparent option for readability so I'm not sure that's Apple's "preferred" experience but at least at first glance the transparent option didn't look as legible.
So some wins, some losses and those losses can be improved in time. Overall the drama seems ... overstated, but then what else is new, especially in certain Mac online communities. To be fair to those communities, I haven't upgraded to Tahoe on the Mac (and iPad is too old I think). I understand macOS is where more people had issues with the new UI. But I suspect I'll probably find it ... at worst okay. To be fair, there were iOS versions I disliked a lot more at first (when they first when all flat, oof, that was rough - I like minimalism but yikes that was too much, especially the ... what is button anymore game).
DT
I am so Smart! S-M-R-T!
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2020
- Posts
- 6,872
- Solutions
- 1
- Main Camera
- iPhone
That's such an odd choice (in iPadOS vs. iOS), I can't believe that's by design, looks like an "oops" to me
Every time you open or switch modes, it shows there are more modes temporarily. It's clever.
The thing I love about spatial mode when it was introduced and now was and is the simplicity. Photo or video. So I liked they brought that to the camera app and I think that's why. They liked the simplicity too. It was getting to the point where there were more buttons everywhere all over the freakin screen
Swipe up on the tab to access all tabs quickly. You can get the other UI styles back in settings if you really want too as well
You should give the original option a chance for a week. If you can't get adjusted to it after a week, then switch. But the clear is really the way to go.
I've seen direct astroturfing, and photo/video manipulation, and so combine that with typical attention seeking the hysteria around the new design is... literally just hysteria. I'm not saying everything is perfect and can't be improved, because that's not what design is. But the "omg this is so horrible" is a bunch of BS lol
Hmmm I guess for me simplicity is showing more of what’s available rather than hiding it. I recognize that there are limits and layers of UI can be necessary but this feels too much hiding. Maybe I’ll change my mind.
While I can’t speak to that, generally people leave comments in the extremes. They either love something or hate it and hate is generally more common and generates more “interest” online, in some places more than others.
You already understand to swipe across modes though, so I'm not sure what difference it makes at this point for you.
Hopefully you took me up on the Safari suggestion. Also if you long press any collapsed tab view in a tab view, you can easily slide over to the other tabs
It’s more that I think it doesn’t look like what it’s trying to convey:
To me this looks like I have the option between photo or video only. Now I know that’s not true, that there are more options if I slide around, but it isn’t immediately intuitive that this isn’t just a toggle between these two options. And I don’t think that’s very good design.
Aye. Thanks.
Last edited:
It... is... that's why I mentioned the animation both when you open the app and when you switch modes lol.
Did you understand what I meant with tab views? Like if you're in Music, and the view collapses to where it's the tab button on the left, music middle, search right, press and hold the left tab and then slide to the tab you want. This is a shortcut so you don't press the tab to open the tab view entirely
If I open the camera app there is no such animation. However, even if there were that’s still not a good UI design in my opinion. Obviously if I am switching modes it pulls out … and then causes other UI elements to disappear. But by then I’m already using it. To me, a UI element should be obvious what it is and how to interact with it at all times not just at specific instances. Ideally I should be able to at a glance, whenever that glance happens, know what a UI element is and how it works.
Yes I understood.
I've seen the animation repeatedly so maybe that's a glitch. The point is you're aware of other options. You do the same actions you did before you updated: slide for another option. There is no problem here. You're sort of arguing to argue.
Quite possible, I’m on an old phone iPhone 12 mini, so it’s entirely possible that things aren’t working quite right. For instance, when I restarted the phone, it lost the wallpaper for some reason.
As for arguing to argue, I’m not the one who engaged here …
My point is considering someone who is unfamiliar with the iPhone, can they immediately point to an element and understand what it is. Yes playing with something they will get used to it but what is better? Something that is obvious with no mental friction or having something that adds just that little bit of mental friction?
This isn’t a deal breaker for me nor a casus belli. It’s just an example of an element of the UI that can be improved. For instance, if you do go to the end of the list the UI is better:
This tells you you've reached the end of the list on the right and the partially cutoff label hints at more to the left without making it look like a toggle. Of course this requires more space and the UI expands to accommodate it, but not that much more.
This is also better in that respect:
You can tell you are in a list with options to the left and right. I do get why they don't do that for the two "defaults". They want photo and video to both be clearly visible as those basic options are the two people will choose most often. But some indication that is there is a list visible at all times is, again, in my opinion, a better design. But I'm not professional app designer as some are on these forums who I'm sure can give their own more studied opinions on UI design than I.
Apple may feel that most people have gotten used to the iOS verbs that they don't need to do this, but I disagree. That kind of thinking is similar to, though not as bad as, the "everything is flat" extremism that stopped Apple from having clearly visible buttons (I will absolutely give credit here to iOS 26 for moving further away from that, that's an improvement). But I feel trying not hide things is generally better (no hard rules) or at least indicate that something is hidden (and not just when you open the app). In macOS I'm the guy who likes the scroll bar always on screen, though I admit the same is not true (were it an option) for the smaller screen and touch based UI of iOS. That's where I'm coming from.
Last edited:
You're expecting me to believe Apple consumers would believe Apple got rid of every camera mode except photo and video, and that the animation wouldn't be enough; and that when they go to tap to switch, that it wouldn't be enough. I think that's a large stretch.
People typically operate stuff without thinking and on muscle memory. Swiping between modes is present. The animation is present.
No design is perfect. I appreciated the last one, and I appreciate this one. What they will do in the future is anyone's guess.
I really enjoy the simplified design.
Interesting:
Multiple people claiming that people are clinging to iOS 18 because iOS 26 is "so bad," yet literally the very design they're clinging to had the same phenomenon of people refusing to update, because they thought it was bad compared to iOS 6. iOS 7's quick adoption rate happened because it was a brand new UI that completely contrasted itself against iOS 6, which people inevitably want to upgrade to. I think iOS 7 is amazing, as is iOS 26. That said, people certainly didn't upgrade to iOS 7 because people thought it would make their iPhone 4 work better... because it certainly did not.
Irony. Almost like they don't have a point, and they're just repeating themselves every time the design changes lol.
For context.
iOS 7 had about 370,000,000 users upgrade to it by December 2013, which is when they reported the user share number.
In contrast, despite Apple NOT pushing iOS 26 and instead actively sending alerts to those on iOS 18 to upgrade to the latest iOS 18, and even HIDING iOS 26 as an option into a bottom section on iOS updates settings page, (up until now with release of 26.2 that has a lot of fixes), 1,128,000,000 users have updated to iOS 26.
3X the users have embraced iOS 26. Over a billion devices. Sort of puts this "catastrophe" into perspective. And let's not even get into the verifiable shit storm Aqua 1.0 brought both technically and community-wise when transitioning to Mac OS X 10.0 lol. Point is, take a break from social media, because it's not nearly as bad as people pretend.
Multiple people claiming that people are clinging to iOS 18 because iOS 26 is "so bad," yet literally the very design they're clinging to had the same phenomenon of people refusing to update, because they thought it was bad compared to iOS 6. iOS 7's quick adoption rate happened because it was a brand new UI that completely contrasted itself against iOS 6, which people inevitably want to upgrade to. I think iOS 7 is amazing, as is iOS 26. That said, people certainly didn't upgrade to iOS 7 because people thought it would make their iPhone 4 work better... because it certainly did not.
Irony. Almost like they don't have a point, and they're just repeating themselves every time the design changes lol.
For context.
iOS 7 had about 370,000,000 users upgrade to it by December 2013, which is when they reported the user share number.
In contrast, despite Apple NOT pushing iOS 26 and instead actively sending alerts to those on iOS 18 to upgrade to the latest iOS 18, and even HIDING iOS 26 as an option into a bottom section on iOS updates settings page, (up until now with release of 26.2 that has a lot of fixes), 1,128,000,000 users have updated to iOS 26.
3X the users have embraced iOS 26. Over a billion devices. Sort of puts this "catastrophe" into perspective. And let's not even get into the verifiable shit storm Aqua 1.0 brought both technically and community-wise when transitioning to Mac OS X 10.0 lol. Point is, take a break from social media, because it's not nearly as bad as people pretend.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2021
- Posts
- 7,632
- Main Camera
- Sony
hadn’t heard a lot of griping other than from developer purists who are complaining about legibility corner cases (and such complaints are good - I hope going forward Apple makes things more legibility). But I stay away from MR and other places that apple-haters like to congregate.
My daughter complained initially about ios 26 but now she seems fine with it - she complained a lot more about prior recent versions of ios. My wife, yesterday, told me she loves how they improved the speaker selection stuff in control center, “but I hate everything else.” I asked what she hated and she would only say “the glass button things.” So her complaint seems more related to fashion than to functionality.
I do have high hopes that the new guy who took over for Alan Dye revamps the Human Interface Guide and sticks to it.
Yoused
up
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2020
- Posts
- 8,230
- Solutions
- 1
I have a second-generation Pro, and I want the pencil-to-text input method to work well for me. It can sometimes be a pleasing alternative to using a keyboard, but iOS 26.2 seems to be worse than it was before. I want Apple to make the pencil UI practical for every day use.
- Joined
- Sep 26, 2021
- Posts
- 7,632
- Main Camera
- Sony
This is a test. Seems to work for me. My handwriting sucks, too. M4 iPad Pro.
Yoused
up
- Joined
- Aug 14, 2020
- Posts
- 8,230
- Solutions
- 1
My complaint is twofold: it is difficult to insert punctuation (especially hyphenated words) and it is a real pain for editing and fixing misread wordscribbles. I had a semi-decent handwriting text app (pre-Pencil), which also had some useful gestures (e.g., quick down+right for return) and gave me better options for interpretation. Also, I was writing into a field and after about three words, it just refused to do any more text. Illegible-scrawl-to-text has worked well for me, and there is a certain rhythm to writing by hand that is just right for some things, but then, if you want to go back to a screen keyboard once the pencil has been used, they make that a real pain. Maybe 27 will offer improvements.