Yeah, I think this is fair at the end of the day, it’s optional, and I’m being hyperbolic lol. It does still feel weird to me seeing it from them even within that constraint but it’s not like the end of the world, also as you say, it’s a beta and they’re known more and more to iron this out thanks to public testers now.Eh. You don’t have to use it. And for the weirdos who like color-coordinating icons and backgrounds and such, they seem to like it. It’s also only the first beta, so maybe some more changes will come (like opting an app icon out).
I think eventually Apple will adopt something like SFSymbols for icons, and then they can do more intelligent tinting.
(As an aside, I want to clarify I think iOS as a whole still blows Android out within apps in terms of UI particularly the moment you get to third-party anything, it’s incredible but sad. software quality is just obscene with iOS — but from a pure aesthetics pov, doing colored icons badly hurts iOS more, but again it’s optional so.)
RE: SFSymbols — I see that this is like their common vector assets for use across UIs and App Icons — you think this could improve representation if developers (and Apple) used more abstract assets like these?
Honestly the dark mode icon change has real potential even if it hurts the aesthetics or design intent for some apps. I do sort of like that if only for easing up on the eyes.