Macrumors still nuking posts without even so much as a word

thekev said:
Somehow I haven't, only warned. This would seem normal if I hadn't seen what others have been suspended for at times.
Click to expand...

That's how it's gone for me over there too. Warned for discussing moderation on the board, when was only trying to help others not get suspensions after I had seen how some of those bans occurred. I still go there when looking for a solution to some obscure Mac-related issue now and then, but that's about it.

EDIT: well I do have to put one good word for maflynn. He said once something about being inattentive one morning and almost putting a polarized plug into the outlet the wrong way around... every time since, before I plug in my kettle I think about that!
 
🙋🏼‍♀️ i was banned twice. on the photography board. one was probably warranted. the other was not. both due to the same person being stupid as rocks.
 
Last edited:
lizkat said:
That's how it's gone for me over there too. Warned for discussing moderation on the board, when was only trying to help others not get suspensions after I had seen how some of those bans occurred.
Click to expand...
Sometimes I wonder if I speak like a politician, because I've never even gotten a warning. I guess I'm not missing out on much.
lizkat said:
well I do have to put one good word for maflynn. He said once something about being inattentive one morning and almost putting a polarized plug into the outlet the wrong way around... every time since, before I plug in my kettle I think about that!
Click to expand...
The only time maflynn ever liked one of my posts was when I described something Rene Ritchie said as "sycophantic". I like Rene, but there were times when he was bit too enthusiastic about Apple, and MR's resident Windows user was all about that. Now, Rene works for Google, so he has suddenly stopped doing the Apple rumors videos with the silly Youtube "shock face" thumbnails that appear to be the norm these days. I'm not sure working for the Borg is an upgrade, but I wish him well.

I don't like dumping on moderators, because it's a thankless job. I'm sure the MR mods must have their reasons, alien though they may be to us on the outside. However, they make it very difficult to muster any measure of sympathy, since they hide everything inside a black box and don't explain it rationally. It's very much "I am the law!", no more, no less.
 
Colstan said:
Sometimes I wonder if I speak like a politician, because I've never even gotten a warning. I guess I'm not missing out on much.

The only time maflynn ever liked one of my posts was when I described something Rene Ritchie said as "sycophantic". I like Rene, but there were times when he was bit too enthusiastic about Apple, and MR's resident Windows user was all about that. Now, Rene works for Google, so he has suddenly stopped doing the Apple rumors videos with the silly Youtube "shock face" thumbnails that appear to be the norm these days. I'm not sure working for the Borg is an upgrade, but I wish him well.

I don't like dumping on moderators, because it's a thankless job. I'm sure the MR mods must have their reasons, alien though they may be to us on the outside. However, they make it very difficult to muster any measure of sympathy, since they hide everything inside a black box and don't explain it rationally. It's very much "I am the law!", no more, no less.
Click to expand...
For Renee every Apple bug is a feature.
 
Eric said:
Well, I would ask who among us has not been suspended over there at one time or another. By all accounts this was an amicable and friendly exchange, Frankie's post was honest and informative, while not insulting anyone. This seemed to be more about them not wanting anyone to vouch for vaccine efficacy than anything to me.
Click to expand...
I haven't been suspended but did receive warnings over stupid shit that probably didn't warrant a warning.
 
Eric said:
One of the few, a sincere congratulations. Their loss is our gain, he'e been a great member of this site and has grown his area nicely, in all the time he's been here he's hasn't misstepped a single time but I think we have an entirely different threshold for that here.
Click to expand...
Well, he is a mod, after all. Suspending a mod is a pretty dire look. Mostly, though, this site seems to have a severe shortage of provocative assholes, thus it is a little harder to actually lose one's patience. Add to that the apparent difference in average age between MR and TA ("apparent" meaning estimated age based on overall behavior), which currently looks to me to be around 1.4. (Generations, that is.)
 
Yoused said:
Well, he is a mod, after all. Suspending a mod is a pretty dire look. Mostly, though, this site seems to have a severe shortage of provocative assholes, thus it is a little harder to actually lose one's patience. Add to that the apparent difference in average age between MR and TA ("apparent" meaning estimated age based on overall behavior), which currently looks to me to be around 1.4. (Generations, that is.)
Click to expand...
And offered the position in short order as well. He came here to post mostly about tech, is both knowledgeable and respected by his peers and most of all, hit by mods at MR, so that ticked all the right boxes for me. For the most part what they find worthy of penalizing people for we find fun and humanizing. @Herdfan can call himself a redneck all day long here and nobody's going to ding him for it. :mrgreen:
 
Last edited:
I haven't been suspended on MR, though I was warned once. TBH, I only go there to see if there are any interesting news or rumors tidbits and occasionally check out some of the technical forums. Being banned wouldn't affect me at all.
 
Eric said:
And offered the position in short order as well. He came here to post mostly about tech, is both knowledgeable and respected by his peers and most of all, hit by mods at MR, so that ticked all the right boxes for me.
Click to expand...

Did you forget to mention he's dreamy?
 
Clix Pix said:
Many of us on the Digital Photography subforum have received at least one suspension thanks to that guy..... He's an irritant beyond belief!
Click to expand...

Curious... what would be a typical cause of someone being suspended on the Digital Photography subform (of all places)?

I never participated on that forum. But have had a few suspensions on the News forum.

As an aside, I'm having an "interesting" conversation there now about photography on the "10 Settings to Check Out on iPhone Pro" thread. About Apple's use of the word "Pro" in iPhone names, what makes a strong photograph and that having very little to do with gear, etc.
 
Citysnaps said:
Curious... what would be a typical cause of someone being suspended on the Digital Photography subform (of all places)?

I never participated on that forum. But have had a few suspensions on the News forum.

As an aside, I'm having an "interesting" conversation there now about photography on the "10 Settings to Check Out on iPhone Pro" thread. About Apple's use of the word "Pro" in iPhone names, what makes a strong photograph and that having very little to do with gear, etc.
Click to expand...
Sometimes all it takes is a single troll to bait and get you penalized, xxxx seems to have been very successful at that.
 
Last edited:
Eric said:
Sometimes all it takes is a single troll to bait and get you penalized, xxxx seems to have been very successful at that.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't say he's a troll, so much as a volatile mix of arrogance, touchiness, and supreme stupidity,
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Renzatic said:
Yeah, but not on purpose. :p
Click to expand...
yeah i agree. his posts are very troll like but he is completely oblivious to it.

fwiw i hate talking about people when they aren’t on the relevant boards to defend themselves. i’ve been that person twice (being talked about elsewhere). but i did actually tell him what i thought of him over there. which got me my first ban. 🙄 i don’t even remember what my second ban was for but he basically reports anyone who disagrees with him which somehow gets the regulars in trouble even with no actual provocation.
 
Regardless of who it is, the pattern is the same with mods there, they only care about what is reported and not about the person baiting others (whether intentional or not). They've denied this on several occasions but their actions consistently show it.
 
Eric said:
Regardless of who it is, the pattern is the same with mods there, they only care about what is reported and not about the person baiting others (whether intentional or not). They've denied this on several occasions but their actions consistently show it.
Click to expand...
It wasn't obvious to me initially, it became a gradual thing, but it's gotten to the point where I parse every damn thing I say over there, like I'm writing my lawyer or Congressman, and not a tech message board. I say this as someone who generally tries to find comity, and has never interacted with the MR mods, but repeatedly held my tongue around the ne'er-do-wells and agitators that pervade that forum. Over here, I say whatever comes to mind, because I don't feel like I'm under the proverbial microscope, which I'm not.
 
Back
Top